Walk past Cape Town’s Golden Acre and you will see more than shoppers, office workers and taxis. You will see people working.
Trolleys filled with clothing, accessories, food and
everyday goods line the pavements around the entrances. For the traders behind
them, this is not a side hustle or something they do when they feel like it. It
is how they pay rent, get to work, feed their families and keep their children
in school.
But for some of these traders, a normal day can change in
minutes.
They say law enforcement officers can arrive, tell them to
close, and remove their goods if they do not move quickly enough. Getting those
goods back can cost money they do not have. And for traders who do not have
valid permits or documents, the fear of losing everything is even greater.
The City of Cape Town says “enforcement is necessary to
manage congestion, unlawful trading and conflict between informal traders and
formal businesses”. But traders describe a system that can feel sudden,
inconsistent and expensive.
More than a trolley
Golden Acre sits in the heart of Cape Town’s CBD. Around it,
the pavement becomes a workplace.
A trolley may look like just a trolley. But for a trader, it
can hold the stock they need to sell that day. If it is removed, they may lose
the goods inside it, lose hours of selling time, and then have to pay to get it
back.
One trader described the fear of stock disappearing during
an operation. For someone relying on daily sales, that is not a small
inconvenience. It can affect whether there is money for food, transport or
school fees.
Many traders were afraid to speak openly about the process.
Some are undocumented or do not have valid trading permits, which makes them
vulnerable. But their stories point to a common concern: enforcement can happen
quickly, and traders are often left uncertain about what happens next.
The city says there is a process.
“According to its impoundment procedure, officials must
complete an inventory, give the trader a copy, say where the goods are stored,
and issue a receipt. The policy also says goods must be handled with care and
protected from damage”.
“In urgent cases, such as when goods are blocking a road or
creating a safety risk, goods may be impounded without prior written notice”.
Even then, the city says an inventory and receipt are still required.
The city’s economic growth directorate says “trading areas
in the Cape Town CBD are demarcated and allocated through established
trading-plan processes. It says the review around Golden Acre included
consultation with affected traders, ward councillors, sub-council
representatives and other stakeholders”.
The city says it considered pedestrian movement, access,
public safety, fire safety and compliance with legislation and bylaws. Where
appropriate, it says alternative trading opportunities were identified for
affected traders.
Law enforcement spokesperson Wayne Dyason says “officers
respond to complaints about illegal or excessive trading, or trading that
blocks business entrances”. He says “officers verify trading documents and
permits before taking action”.
On the recent removal of trolleys from the Grand Parade, Dyason said “the operation followed complaints that traders were keeping trolleys overnight on city land”. He said “compliance notices were issued before confiscation, traders were told where the trolleys were impounded, and they were told when to pay and collect their goods”.
Not everyone has the same experience
Not every trader at Golden Acre has the same relationship
with the city.
Some say they have permits. Others say their permits were
issued through the plaza or a trader structure rather than directly by the
city.
William Okori, a trader from Nigeria, says he has
identification and a permit, and pays monthly to trade in the area.
“I have my ID. I have my permit,” he says. “This shop comes
from the plaza. We have all the permit before going to the plaza.”
Okori says law enforcement, Home Affairs and immigration
officers visit the area at different times. He keeps his documents ready.
“The law enforcement comes here every month or every
quarterly, including Home Affairs, including customs, including immigration
officers,” he says. “They do come here whenever they feel like. If they ask for
it, I will show them. Anytime, anywhere, I’m going to always have it.”
But Okori says he has not personally experienced forced
removal in his section of the pavement.
“Nobody has been forcibly removed from here because, to me,
I will speak of myself,” he says. “I don’t know what happens on the other side.
It has never happened to me.”
His experience matters because it shows that Golden Acre is
not one simple story. Some traders say they have documents, pay fees and have
not been removed. Others say they face repeated removals, payments and
uncertainty.
When a permit disappears
For traders without documents, the consequences can be
immediate.
One trader says he lost his permit after it fell from his
pocket. Without it, his ability to trade and to explain why he should be
allowed to stay becomes far more difficult.
Another trader says permits must be renewed every month and
that there is a cost involved.
“We apply by the City officer,” the trader says. “It’s not
for free when you qualify for this. You apply and they check it. You renew it every
month.”
The city says traders who breach permit conditions or bylaws
may receive written warnings. Depending on the offence, goods may be impounded
after repeated breaches. Illegal goods may be confiscated immediately.
But the question remains: when goods are removed, does every
trader receive the required notice, inventory and receipt? And are the fees
traders pay official fees or something else?
Claims that need answers
Some traders allege that money sometimes changes hands
outside a formal receipt or official process. Others allege that stock goes
missing and that traders are not treated the same way.
These are serious allegations. The city has not confirmed
them, and they should not be treated as established facts.
What can be checked is whether removals follow a documented
process: warning, inventory, receipt, storage and release.
Paperwork matters here. Notices, receipts, inventories and
payment records can show whether the city’s policy is being applied consistently
or whether there is a gap between what is written down and what traders
experience on the pavement.
Living with uncertainty
Behind the policy language are people trying to earn a
living.
A removed trolley can mean lost stock, lost selling time and
a fee to get back to work. For traders who say this happens again and again,
the cost is not only financial.
It is the stress of never knowing whether tomorrow will be a
normal trading day.
“Trading is not made for it. You must check for it,” one
trader says. “Sometimes every day. If they come, we close. If they come, we
stay close.”
That uncertainty changes how people work. Some traders say they spend the day watching and waiting, ready to pack up at a moment’s notice.
What needs to change
The city says it enforces bylaws to manage congestion,
unlawful trading and conflict around Golden Acre. It says “traders were
consulted, alternative bays were identified where appropriate, and that traders
collected impounded trolleys after paying”.
Traders want something simpler: clear rules, fair treatment,
proper receipts, and answers when their goods go missing.
They want to know where their goods are taken, what they
must pay, and who is accountable if something goes wrong.
For now, the pavement outside Golden Acre remains a
workplace. But for some traders, it is also a place where a day’s income can
disappear along with their goods.
Written by: Jasnine Roberts





